WHAT IF SCHOOLS VALUED WELLBEING MORE THAN RESULTS? (adapted from the writings of Dr Tara Porter*)
“The New Zealand government puts mental health above economic stability. Should our schools do the same?”
Governments throughout the world organise their budgets with the aim of economic stability and growth. The New Zealand (NZ) government has become one of the first governments in the world to turn this idea on its head. They have designed their budget not around monetary aims but around wellbeing aims.
In the UK, David Cameron suggested a decade back that the UK should move away from an obsession with gross domestic product to instead focus on general wellbeing, but the idea remained purely speculative, and our budgeting continues on economic grounds. Was this more than just an interesting 'insight' way back then?
However, at this point in time, even some economists want a change in focus. For example, Professor Lord Richard Layard, from the Centre for Economic Performance at the London School of Economics, recently proposed "that the Comprehensive Spending Review should be organised around prioritising mental health" (Today, Radio 4, May 25).
It is hypothesised that such a move would stimulate economic growth as well as personal happiness – presumably because we would be more productive, take fewer days off sick, have fewer costly problems in our relationships, and so on.
What has NZ done? The NZ government established five key areas as part of its Wellbeing Budget:
1. Taking mental health seriously, through investment in front-line services, housing and addiction.
2. Improving child welfare, especially for children in care or living in poverty, and for victims of sexual and family violence.
3. Supporting Maori and Pasifika aspirations, through investing in community health programmes and projects to reduce reoffending.
4. Building a productive nation through technology and vocational education.
5. Transforming into an ecologically sustainable economy, through reducing emissions and investing in public transport.
What if we did this in education? What if the Department of Education, local education authorities, schools and academies had to adopt versions of these five ideas as their central tenets? How would this play out for the mental health and wellbeing of our children and future generations? So, here goes with just a few suggestions:
1. TAKING CHILD MENTAL HEALTH SERIOUSLY:
- Of course (nearly) all schools take mental health seriously, but what if they put it first, before any other responsibility? What if their primary purpose was to educate children to have a happy and healthy life?
- There are economic as well as social arguments for this, as 50 per cent of all adult mental health problems start before the age of 14, and the total cost to the economy of mental health problems would clearly be reduced?
- Schools would not be ranked on the basis of academic output, but instead on children’s emotional wellbeing. The success of a school would, therefore, be determined not by its entries to top universities but by its ability to produce mentally well grown-ups.
- Children need clear boundaries and rules, based on mutual respect and responsibility, to help them feel emotionally contained and cared for – so that would need to be the basis for school discipline. This is the stuff that helps children to develop resilience.
- Some children from troubled homes might need highly skilled outreach into their family or community in order to be able to manage such a structured setting, but this would be an investment in avoiding future social and mental health problems.
- Child and adolescent mental health services and education would be fully integrated, and there would be a high level of pastoral care, in an effort to prevent problems such as addiction and bullying by intervening before they arose.
2. IMPROVING CHILD WELLBEING:
- It is well established that some children from certain social groups underperform in school, and also that poverty in adulthood is linked to mental health problems.
- But research suggests that it is not helpful for psychological health for one group of children to feel they have failed at 11.
- We now know that the mental health impact of putting children through a competitive, relentlessly academic school system. While some children thrive there, others will crash and burn.
- A broad curriculum is probably the best way to capture the skills and imaginations of a broad cohort of children, based on equal respect for traditional academic subjects as well as practical, vocational skills, and including plenty of extracurricular activities.
- Prioritise giving all teachers (and school staff members) time to listen and to be role models, rather than focusing exclusively on exam results.
3. SUPPORTING DISADVANTAGED GROUPS THROUGH COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE AND REDUCING REOFFENDING:
- The NZ government is trying to offer equality of opportunity by reaching out to indigenous groups who have suffered discrimination. In AU, we clearly have different issues in relation to cultural identity and integration.
- The challenge is how groups disengaged by education can be re-engaged. While other nations have moved towards having less segregated school systems to address these issues, the UK seems to be going the opposite way.
- It is clear that many parents value selection by religion, wealth or intelligence, and that being educated with like-minded folk promotes their sense of community.
- Others may believe it embeds social inequality and prejudice.
- Current International research suggests that desegregated schools have long-term benefits including in terms of wellbeing and offending rates.
4. BUILDING A PRODUCTIVE NATION BASED TECHNOLOGY & VOCATIONAL EDUCATION:
- Past reforms took schools back to a more traditional education, based on academia, knowledge and fact-learning.
- NZ is heading in a different direction, based on technology and vocational learning. A NZ model would move away from knowledge-based learning, towards computing, business and the arts, as well as practical and local skills.
- It also seems that a broad curriculum is better for mental health, as it gives children opportunity to find something they are good at, and to express their emotions through art and sport.
5. TRANSFORMING THE ECONOMY TO ONE WITH A LOW ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT:
- There would need to be at least two strands to adopting this standard in education.
- The first is how we educate a generation with the skills to solve the environmental problem.
- The second is how to make the process of education carbon-neutral.
- This would in all likelihood impact on every part of the school day. Are school dinners or packed lunches environmentally friendly? What are the teaching methods that create the best educational outcomes and the least waste?
- Why don't parents let their children walk to school, or go out alone without an adult? Parents shouldn't have to justify it – let’s face it, sadly peer pressure keeps kids from walking to school and this should not be the case – “It’s cool to walk to school!” (check out this related article): https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/i-shouldnt-have-to-justify-it-peer-pressure-keeps-kids-from-walking-to-school-20171205-gzyrtc.html
- One environmental factor, which also impacts on physical and mental health, would be children walking to school. Children travel further to school than they did a generation ago, and because of this are more likely to be driven.
- Would this mean school allocation moved back to distance rather than parental choice? And would that act to improve social integration or embed it?
A SCHOOL SYSTEM UTOPIA? – OR DOES IT HAVE REALISTIC POTENTIAL?
Dr Tara Porter’s speculations about the impact of adopting the tenets of the New Zealand budget in all schools are obviously purely hypothetical. Her inferences create a fantasy of schools not just being at the heart of their community but creating a community close to where their pupils live.
These schools would be based on cultural respect and integration, with no child being left behind or excluded from education. They would offer a high-quality technological, academic and artistic curriculum, and a high level of pastoral care, so that every child was offered equality and the opportunity to succeed, without being put under so much pressure that they broke down.
It’s purely a speculative daydream, but isn’t it rather a nice one? Food for thought and further discussion?
* Dr Tara Porter is a clinical psychologist at the Royal Free London NHS Trust & also at the Anna Freud National Centre for Children & Families (UK).
Did you like this one? ... want more?
Check out below this recent blog on a similar topic by Jacqueline Victoria Prooday at georgina@wellbeingforkids:
Reasons Today’s Kids Are Bored at School, Feel Entitled, Have Little Patience & Few Real Friends
She writes: "I am an occupational therapist with years of experience working with children, parents, and teachers. I completely agree with this teacher’s message that our children are getting worse and worse in many aspects. I hear the same consistent message from every teacher I meet. Clearly, throughout my time as an Occupational Therapist, I have seen and continue to see a decline in kids’ social, emotional, and academic functioning, as well as a sharp increase in learning disabilities and other diagnoses. As we know, the brain is malleable. Through environment, we can make the brain “stronger” or make it “weaker”. I truly believe that, despite all our greatest intentions, we unfortunately remold our children’s brains in the wrong direction." Read more...
BALI UPDATE: EN-MASS TOURISM & OTHER ONGOING ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES ON THE ‘ISLAND OF PARADISE’Now this is NOT the story that you will hear from your local travel agent, it’s not hidden in their tourist brochures, and you certainly won’t get it from the Indonesian Government. Why? That’s because it’s all about greed, politics and excrement - literally! It's not pretty.En-mass tourism [...]
THE COST OF GLORY — CLIMBING MOUNT EVEREST (2019)by Amit Chowdhury* Aspiring to climb Everest has never been so big. 77 Indians this year constitute the largest number from any single country. Already four of these are dead and several have had to be rescued. Not by any accident, such as a fall or avalanche but by sheer [...]
MEN, BOYS AND MENTAL HEALTHToxic masculinity can create a barrier to seeking help, with devastating consequencesArticle by Nick Cardone* Background: Nick Cardone is a Registered Counselling Therapist in Nova Scotia (Canada). He is also the Owner and Lead Clinician at Free Range Therapy – a private therapy clinic specialized in working with men and adolescent boys.“A culture clash exists between [...]
COULD YOUR OUTDOOR WILDERNESS-ADVENTURE THERAPY PROGRAM AFFORD A LAWSUIT ?An Organisation’s Motto Should Be: “Your Safety is Our Commitment to You” Caveat: Generally speaking, this is a topic that most people don't like to talk about, let alone like to read about. However, in my own defense, good risk management and safety awareness are essential to [...]
Student Support Services & other ‘specialised' outdoor programming services provided to our WA schoolsThe Education industry reports that outdoor education is highly valuable in terms of its ability to develop technical skills to undertake different activities safely in the natural environment, an appreciation for the environment, as well as broader personal development in terms of leadership and interpersonal skills. [...]
THE BENEFITS OF CAMP SCHOOLS WITH STUDENTS (Part 2)Education Department staff: "WA Camp Schools – Experts in student residential outdoor education, adventure-based learning, team building, pro-social skills training and resilience!" Our Camp Schools certainly are considered an essential part of the educational curriculum and they are designed to support a variety of areas of learning in each child’s personal and [...]
The Benefits of Camp Schools with Students (Part 1)There is no better way to help a student than to inspire them, and an unforgettable residential Camp School experience can do just that. It can offer a wonderful opportunity to open young minds and nurture their potential, to teach life skills, boost a sense of belonging, build confidence and create [...]
SAFETY & RISK MANAGEMENT PRACTICES WITHIN THE AUSTRALIAN OUTDOOR ADVENTURE INDUSTRY: Inland Water Paddle-Craft Guide
SAFETY & RISK MANAGEMENT PRACTICES WITHIN THE AUSTRALIAN OUTDOOR ADVENTURE INDUSTRY: INLAND WATER PADDLE-CRAFTThis post is part of a series of related articles on the outdoor adventure tourism industry and also safety & risk management practicesOver the past decade, the Australian outdoors community has been working on developing the ‘Australian Adventure Activity Standards’ (Australian AAS). The [...]
HOW TO BECOME AN OUTDOOR ADVENTURE GUIDE: A CAREER PATH GUIDE TO WORKING IN THE GREAT OUTDOORSHave you ever dreamed of working in the great outdoors as an Outdoor Adventure Guide or an Outdoor Instructor.* Do you hold an active interest in adventurous activities?* Do you have a strong passion for working the outdoors in [...]